Office of Parliamentary Counsel  
    Home | About | News | Site Map | Contact Us | Search

CALC - Papers

Download PDF version Download PDF version| Download RTF version Download RTF version

For a more comprehensive list of articles in the Loophole and the CALC Newsletter, please see the CALC catalogue in the table below

CALC Catalogue - Loophole and CALC Newsletter articles
Current edition of CALC catalogue - updated January 2012 Download PDF format
293k
Download RTF format
854k
1st edition of CALC catalogue - published in the February 2011 edition of Loophole Download PDF format
388k
Download RTF format
222k

Papers

Organised by year of publication in The Loophole.

2011 | 2010 | 2009 | 2008 | 2007 | 2005 | 2004 | 2001 | 1998 | 1997 | 1995 | 1990 | 1989 | undated

[return to top]

2011
Legislative Drafting: Art, Science or Discipline?
This article by Sandra Markman was published in the November 2011 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
218k
 
The Role and Efficacy of Legislative Drafting in the United States: An Update on the American Drafting Process
This article by Douglass Bellis was published in the November 2011 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
221k
 
Emerging from the Shadow - Legislative Drafting in Gibraltar
This article by Paul Peralta was published in the November 2011 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
254k
 
"High-quality" Legislation - (How) Can Legislative Counsel Facilitate It?
This article by Ross Carter was published in the November 2011 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
449k
 
The Role and Efficacy of Legislation
This article by Sudha Rani was published in the November 2011 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
206k
 
Training and Development of Legislative Counsel in Commonwealth Africa - the Way Forward
This article by Estelle Appiah was published in the November 2011 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
222k
 
The Language of the Law: How do we need to use language in drafting legislation?
This article by Roger Rose was published in the August 2011 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
296k
 
Legislative Drafting in Mauritius: A Developing Discipline
This article by Sir Victor Glover was published in the August 2011 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
171k
 
Behind-the-Scenes Actors? Towards Enhancing the Visibility of Legislative Counsel in Developing Countries
This article by Elizabeth Martha Bakibinga was published in the August 2011 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
442k
 
Testing Client Policy: The Emperor's Clothes
This article by Paul Salembier was published in the August 2011 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
259k
 
The Wavering Line between Policy Development and Legislative Drafting
This article by Elizabeth Grant was published in the August 2011 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
198k
 
The Wavering Line between Policy Development and Legislative Drafting
This article by Therese Perera was published in the August 2011 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
202k
 
Human Rights: the Role of Legislative Counsel
This article by Daniel Lovric was published in the August 2011 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
321k
 
Legislative drafting in Sri Lanka
This article by Therese Perera was published in the May 2011 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
94k
 
A bonfire of the criminal laws? A review of Law Commission Consultation Paper no195: Criminal liability in regulatory contexts?
This article by Kiron Reid was published in the May 2011 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
236k
 
Purpose sections: Why they are a good idea for drafters and users
This article by Duncan Berry was published in the May 2011 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
171k
 
Legislative Drafting in South Sudan
This article by William E. Kosar was published in the May 2011 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
124k
 
The virtue in an Old Act
This article by David Hull was published in the May 2011 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
87k
 
Duncan Berry: a full life in progress
This article by John Moloney was published in the February 2011 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
51k
 

Short History of the Commonwealth Association of Legislative Counsel
This article by Walter Iles QC was published in the February 2011 issue of The Loophole.

Download PDF format
99k
 

Duncan Berry: A visionary of training in legislative drafting
This article by Dr Helen Xanthaki was published in the February 2011 issue of The Loophole.

Download PDF format
133k
 

Work methods and processes in a drafting environment
This article by Lionel A. Levert QC was published in the February 2011 issue of The Loophole.

Download PDF format
91k
 

Shaping policy into law: A strategy for developing common standards
This article by Nick Horn was presented at the CALC Africa Region conference, Nigeria, April 2010, and was published in the February 2011 issue of The Loophole.

Download PDF format
172k
 

Sustainable Drafting
This article by John Mark Keyes was published in the February 2011 issue of The Loophole.

Download PDF format
80k
 

Giving effect to policy in legislation: how to avoid missing the point
This article by Sir Stephen Laws, KCB was published in the February 2011 issue of The Loophole, and is a lecture delivered on 10 November 2010 as the Statute Law Society's Lord Renton Lecture at the Institute of Advanced Legal Studies.

Download PDF format
129k
 

Accessibility of European Union legislation
This article by William Robinson was published in the February 2011 issue of The Loophole.

Download PDF format
169k
 

A survey of users attitudes to the use of aids to understanding in legislation
This article by Peter Quiggin, PSM was published in the February 2011 issue of The Loophole.

Download PDF format
70k
 

The three myths of plain English drafting
This article by Daniel Greenberg was published in the February 2011 issue of The Loophole.

Download PDF format
133k
 

It's Just Your Imagination - Some Thoughts on the Role of Parliamentary Counsel in Ensuring Practicability of Legislative Instruments
This article by Sandra Markman was published in the February 2011 issue of The Loophole.

Download PDF format
54k
 

[return to top]

2010

Drafting Legislative Provisions: Challenges and Opportunities
This article by Vijay K Bhatia was published in the December 2010 issue of The Loophole.

Download PDF format
85k
 

Principles-based drafting: experiences from tax drafting
This article by Daniel Lovric was published in the December 2010 issue of The Loophole.

Download PDF format
124k
 

Statutory Adjudication Under Nine Commonwealth Jurisdictions - A User's Perspective on Legislative Drafting Style
This article by NAN Ameer Ali and Dr S Wilkinson was presented at the CALC conference, Hong Kong, April 2009, and published in the December 2010 issue of The Loophole.

Download PDF format
401k
 

Legislative Drafting: A Lawmaker's Perspective
This article by Margaret Ng was published in the December 2010 issue of The Loophole.

Download PDF format
103k
 

The consultative process in social policy legislation: the experience of Ghana in the Property Rights of Spouses Bill
This article by Estelle Appiah was published in the August 2010 issue of The Loophole, and is an edited version of a paper presented at the CALC Africa Region conference, Nigeria, April 2010.

Download PDF format
62k

The difficulties of teaching legislation to students
This article by John Burrows was published in the August 2010 issue of The Loophole, and is an edited version of a paper presented at the CALC conference, Hong Kong, April 2009.
Download PDF format
116k
 

The long march: pen and paper drafting to E-publishing law
This article by Don Colagiuri SC and Michael Rubacki was published in the August 2010 issue of The Loophole, and is an edited version of a paper presented at the CALC conference, Hong Kong, April 2009.

Download PDF format
125k
 

Bi-lingual Drafting in Hong Kong
This article by Tony Yen was published in the August 2010 issue of The Loophole, and is an edited version of a paper presented at the CALC conference, Hong Kong, April 2009.

Download PDF format
43k
 

Keepers of the Statute Book: Lessons from the space-time continuum
This article by Janet Erasmus was presented at the CALC conference, Hong Kong, April 2009, and published in the January 2010 issue of The Loophole.

Download PDF format
450k

Legislative drafting: a judicial perspective
This article by Hon. Mr Justice Bokhary PJ was presented at the CALC conference, Hong Kong, April 2009, and published in the January 2010 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
78k

Scrutiny of legislative drafting by the Legislature: The role of the legal Advisers of the Hong Kong Legislative Council
This article by Jimmy Ma was presented at the CALC conference, Hong Kong, April 2009, and published in the January 2010 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
47k

Whose law is it? A jurilinguistic view from the trenches
This article by Lise Poirier was presented at the CALC conference, Hong Kong, April 2009, and published in the January 2010 issue of The Loophole
Download PDF format
63k

Legislative counsel and pre-legislative scrutiny
This article by Stephen Argument was presented at the CALC conference, Hong Kong, April 2009, and published in the January 2010 issue of The Loophole
Download PDF format
61k

Legalese and plain language
This article by Mark Adler was presented at the CALC conference, Hong Kong, April 2009, and published in the January 2010 issue of The Loophole
Download PDF format
48k

[return to top]

2009

Professional Responsibilities of Legislative Counsel
This article by John Mark Keyes was presented at the CALC conference, Hong Kong, April 2009, and published in the October 2009 issue of The Loophole.

Download PDF format
147k
Download RTF format
383k

Consistency versus Innovation
This article by Stephen Laws was presented at the CALC conference, Hong Kong, April 2009, and published in the October 2009 issue of The Loophole.

Download PDF format
41k
Download RTF format
112k

Access to Legislation - the Legislative Counsel's Role
This article by Daniel Greenberg was presented at the CALC conference, Hong Kong, April 2009, and published in the October 2009 issue of The Loophole.

Download PDF format
40k
Download RTF format
1.1M

Whose Law is it? - Accessibility through LENZ
This article by Melanie Bromley was presented at the CALC conference, Hong Kong, April 2009, and published in the October 2009 issue of The Loophole.

Download PDF format
266k
Download RTF format
1.5M

Problems in drafting anti-terrorism laws in Australia
This article by Meredith Leigh was presented at the CALC conference, Nairobi, September 2007, and published in the June 2009 issue of The Loophole.

Download PDF format
28k
Download RTF format
102kb
Enforcement Mechanisms (including Alternatives to Criminal Penalties)
This article by Eamonn Moran was presented at the CALC conference, Nairobi, September 2007, and published in the June 2009 issue of The Loophole
Download PDF format
35k
Download RTF format
88kb
The Need for Simplicity in Legislation and Challenges in its Attainment
This article by Fredrick Ruhindi MP was presented at the CALC conference, Nairobi, September 2007, and published in the June 2009 issue of The Loophole
Download PDF format
42k
Download RTF format
139kb
Keeping the Statute Book up to date - a self-help guide
This article by Jeremy Wainwright was presented at the CALC conference, Nairobi, September 2007, and published in the June 2009 issue of The Loophole
Download PDF format
54k
Download RTF format
264kb
One Giant Leap - The Ultimate Legislation System, Available Now
This article by Ed Hicks was presented at the CALC conference, Nairobi, September 2007, and published in the June 2009 issue of The Loophole
Download PDF format
50k
Download RTF format
106kb

[return to top]

2008
The impact of judicial interpretation on legislative drafting
This article by The Rt. Hon. Lady Justice Mary Arden DBE was presented at the CALC conference, Nairobi, September 2007, and published in the August 2008 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
105k
Download RTF format
2.8M
In support of plain law: an answer to Francis Bennion
This article by Mark Adler was presented at the CALC conference, Nairobi, September 2007, and published in the August 2008 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
221k
Download RTF format
1.9M
The Role of Legislative Counsel: Wordsmith or Counsel?
This article by David Hull was presented at the CALC conference, Nairobi, September 2007, and published in the August 2008 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
79k

Download RTF format
7.9M

The Role of Legislative Counsel: Wordsmith or Counsel?
This article by Stephen Laws was presented at the CALC conference, Nairobi, September 2007, and published in the August 2008 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
154k
Download RTF format
102k
The Delegation by Parliament of its legislative powers: a South African perspective
This article by Deon Rudman was presented at the CALC conference, Nairobi, September 2007, and published in the August 2008 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
125k
Download RTF format
1.5M

[return to top]

2007
Straddling a barbed wire fence: reflections of a gamekeeper, turned poacher, turned gamekeeping poacher
This article by Stephen Argument was presented to the Australia - New Zealand Scrutiny of Legislation Conference, Wellington, New Zealand, 31 July to 2 August 2007, and published in the October 2007 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
248k
Download RTF format
222k
Statute Revision in British Columbia: Recent developments from a jurisdiction with a long history of statute revision
This article by Janet Erasmus was presented at the CALC conference, London, September 2005, and published in the October 2007 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
321k
Download RTF format
311k
Keeping the Statute Book up-to-date - A personal view
This article by Duncan Berry was presented at the CALC conference, London, September 2005, and published in the October 2007 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
356k
Download RTF format
297k
Aspects of law revision in the Commonwealth
This article by Neil Adsett was presented at the CALC conference, London, September 2005, and published in the October 2007 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
295k
Download RTF format
771k
The nature of legislative intention and its implications for legislative drafting
This article by Daniel Greenberg was presented at the CALC conference, London, September 2005, and published in the October 2007 issue of The Loophole. It was originally published in the Statute Law Review, Volume 27, No.1, 2006, pp.15-28.
Download PDF format
254k
Download RTF format
226k
Drafting against a background of differing legal systems: Scots law and the UK statute book
This article by Colin Wilson was published in the July 2007 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
163k
Download RTF format
20k
Drafting against a background of differing legal systems: Canadian bijuralism
This article by Marc Cuerrier was published in the July 2007 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
318k
Download RTF format
123k
What, how, when and why-making laws easier to understand by using examples and notes
This 2005 article by Ben Piper was published in the July 2007 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
257k
Download RTF format
110k
Statutory interpretation and human rights
This article by the Rt Hon Lady Justice Arden D.B.E. was presented at the CALC conference, September 2005, and published in the July 2007 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
228k
Download RTF format
55k
'Challenges of drafting in a developing country'
This article by John F. Wilson was presented at the CALC conference, July 2005, and published in the July 2007 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
162k
Download RTF format
20k
Electronic publication of New Brunswick legislation-yesterday, today and tomorrow
This article by Judith Keating QC was presented at the CALC conference, London, September 2005, and published in the July 2007 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
193k
Download RTF format
26k
Training and development of legislative drafters
This article by Peter Quiggin (First Parliamentary Counsel) was presented at the CALC conference, London, September 2005, and published in the July 2007 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
283k
Download RTF format
115k
Address on the organisation of drafting offices
This article by Don Colagiuri SC was presented to the CALC conference, London, September 2005, and published in the July 2007 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
230k
Download RTF format
40k
The effect of poorly written legislation in a bilingual legal system
This article by Duncan Berry was published in the March 2007 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
155k
Download RTF format
39k
Legal briefs and lawful shorts-Are they for you?
This article by Janet E. Erasmus was published in the March 2007 of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
183k
Download RTF format
50k
Polishing what others have written: the role of the European Commission's legal revisers in drafting European Community legislation
This article by William Robinson was published in the March 2007 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
198k
Download RTF format
103k
Legislative and Regulatory Reform Act 2006 (UK)
This article by Duncan Berry was published in the March 2007 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
179k
Download RTF format
56k
Henry VIII clauses: Their birth, a late 20th century renaissance and a possible 21st century metamorphosis
This article by Dennis Morris was published in the March 2007 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
472k
Download RTF format
497k
Democratic reform and private members' business: Shifting sands or paradigms?
This article by John Mark Keyes was published in the March 2007 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
182k
Download RTF format
50k

[return to top]

2005
Legislative drafting in Australia, New Zealand and Ontario: Notes on an informal survey
This article by Nick Horn was first presented at the conference of the Canadian Institute for the Administration of Justice in Ottawa in September 2002. The survey was updated and the notes significantly revised in March/April 2003 for presentation at the CALC conference in May 2003. The survey and notes were further updated and published in the March 2005 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
219k
Download RTF format
623k
Use and misuse of examples
This article by Paul O'Brien is based on a paper presented at the CALC conference, Melbourne, April 2003, and was published in the March 2005 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
45k
Download RTF format
36k
Instant Bills: The impact of information technology (IT) on legislative drafting in Canada
This article by Don Macpherson was published in the March 2005 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
160k
Download RTF format
72k
Notes on the information technology system (IT) used in the Australian Commonwealth Office of Parliamentary Counsel
This article by Peter Quiggin (First Parliamentary Counsel) was published in the March 2005 issue of The Loophole. The notes were handed out at the CALC conference, Melbourne, April 2003.
Download PDF format
66k
Download RTF format
108k
Legislative drafting training in the Hong Kong Department of Justice
This article by Duncan Berry was published in the March 2005 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
47k
Download RTF format
27k
Some aspects of compliance with UN Security Council Resolution 1373
This article by Jeremy Wainwright was published in the March 2005 issue of The Loophole. The paper was written for presentation at the CALC conference, Melbourne, 2003, but was not presented due to a time clash.
Download PDF format
44k
Download RTF format
30k

[return to top]

2004
"Union" Jack and the GM Beanstalk-A European Union fable
This article by Dennis Morris was published in the 2004 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
136k
Download RTF format
163k
Developments in the delegation of legislative powers in Ireland
This article by Jonathan Buttimore was published in the 2004 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
38k
Download RTF format
163k
Required rule-making: When do you have to make delegated legislation?
This article by John Mark Keyes was published in the 2004 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
211k
Download RTF format
302k
Multilingualism and the authoring of laws
This article by Donald L. Revell was published in the 2004 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
275k
Download RTF format
197k
Supporting legislative drafting in Bangladesh
This article by Lionel Levert QC was published in the 2004 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
154k
Download RTF format
200k
Shining examples
This article by Jeffrey Barnes was published in the 2004 issue of The Loophole and is a revised and expanded version of a paper originally presented at the CALC conference in Melbourne on 17 April 2003.
Download PDF format
172k
Download RTF format
285k

[return to top]

2001
A guide for effective legislative drafting instructions
This article from the Office of the Queensland Parliamentary Counsel was published in the 2001 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
164k
Download RTF format
271k
The importance of getting savings and transitionals right: Two contrasting cases
This article by Duncan Berry was published in the 2001 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
68k
Download RTF format
140k
Parliament cannot delegate its legislative power: A British constitutional reality or myth?
This article by Dennis Morris was published in the 2001 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
62k
Download RTF format
128k
"Prince Splendid and the dream machine"-A fairytale for legislative counsel
This article by John Wilson was published in the 2001 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
34k
Download RTF format
113k
The legislation process course run by the Australian Commonwealth Office of Parliamentary Counsel
This article by Iain McMillan and Camilla Webster was published in the 2001 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
45k
Download RTF format
132k
The commencement conundrum: How the Fiji Islands banking system was brought to a standstill
This article by John F.Wilson was published in the 2001 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
108k
Download RTF format
117k
Lessons for Statutory Drafters from the Florida election dispute
This article by Jack Stark was published in the 2001 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
45k
Download RTF format
114k

[return to top]

1998
The Year 2000 Problem-A New South Wales Perspective
This article by Michael Rubacki first appeared in the 1998 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
54k
Download RTF format
40k
Drafting the New South Wales Duties Act 1997
This article by Michael Orpwood QC first appeared in the 1998 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
54k
Download RTF format
71k
Rewriting Australia's Income Tax Law
This article by Kerry Jones first appeared in the 1998 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
148k
Download RTF format
207k
Opening Speeches-At the Conference Marking the 25th Anniversary of the OPC in Canberra 1995
This item first appeared in the 1998 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
131k
Download RTF format
150k
Linguistics and Legislation: Some Comments
This article by Jonathan Woodger first appeared in the 1998 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
31k
Download RTF format
43k
"From Time to Time"
This article by Fabian Flintoff first appeared in the 1998 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
26k
Download RTF format
33k
Show, Don't Tell! A Graphic Approach to Amendment of Legislation
This article by Nicholas Horn was first published in The Loophole in 1998. An earlier version of this paper was given at the conference on legislative drafting hosted by OPC, 10-11 August 1995.
Download PDF format
114k
Download RTF format
131k
Drafting From a Blueprint
This article by Adrian Van Wierst was first published in The Loophole in 1998, and is an edited transcript of a talk given at the conference on legislative drafting hosted by OPC, 10-11 August 1995.
Download PDF format
104k
Download RTF format
133k

[return to top]

1997
Bilingual Legislative Texts and the Problem of Textual Ambiguities
This article by Suen Wai-chung was first published in The Loophole in December 1997.
Download PDF format
107k
 
Plain Language In New Zealand Tax Legislation
This article by Elizabeth A. McAra was first published in The Loophole in March 1997.
Download PDF format
44k
Download RTF format
68k

Techniques for Evaluating Draft Legislation
This article by Duncan Berry was first published in The Loophole in March 1997 and is based on a paper presented at the CALC conference held in Vancouver, September 1996.

Download PDF format
176k
Download RTF format
201k

Why Legislative Drafting Services Should Not Be Privatised
This article by Duncan Berry was first published in The Loophole in March 1997 and is based on a paper presented at the CALC conference held in Vancouver, September 1996.

Download PDF format
32k
Download RTF format
31k

Confidential Review of Draft Legislation By Members of Private Bar
A brief discussion of the British Columbia experience
This article by Janet Erasmus and Ann McLean was first published in The Loophole in March 1997 and is based on a paper presented at the CALC conference held in Vancouver, September 1996.

Download PDF format
67k
Download RTF format
41k

[return to top]

1995

Plain Language and Drafting in General Principles
This article by Ian Turnbull QC (former First Parliamentary Counsel) was first published in The Loophole in 1995.

Download PDF format
87k
Download RTF format
144k

[return to top]

1990
Clear Legislative Drafting: New Approaches in Australia
This article by Ian Turnbull (former First Parliamentary Counsel) was first published on 6 October 1990.
Download PDF format
183k
Download RTF format
318k

[return to top]

1989
Efficiency in Legal Drafting
This article by Professor Robert D Eagleson was first published in the 1989 issue of The Loophole.
Download PDF format
107k
Download RTF format
164k

[return to top]

undated
Bilingual Drafting in Canada
Article by Lionel A. Levert.
Download PDF format
45k
Download RTF format
40k

Hansard - Help or Hindrance? A Draftsman's View of Pepper v Hart
Article by Francis Bennion.

Download PDF format
200k
Download RTF format
143k

When Does An Instrument Made Under Primary Legislation Have "Legislative Effect"?
Article by Duncan Berry.

Download PDF format
179k
Download RTF format
174k

 

 
 


Copyright | Privacy | Disclaimer | FOI | Contact Us | Feedback | Search | Top